"Even those who do not, or cannot, avail themselves of a
scientific education, choose to benefit from the technology
that is made possible by the scientific education of others."-- Richard Dawkins, "A Devil's Chaplain"
Morris Guadalcanal wants some serious improvement talk.
Out on a long training run on a club night, he's fallen in step
with Osprey Lyons and Davida Desmond, both of whom he
knows better by reputation than in person. Osprey coaches
at a high school. Davida has made a name for herself in her
age group in big marathons.
According to Morris's thinking, one or both might have an
answer to a hurdle he's run into. A mainstay at middle
distances at a state university a decade ago, Morris decided
early in the year to extend his race mileage. To his surprise
he sustains such high rates of speed over the long haul that
he finds himself on the heels of runners he'd never thought
to challenge.
The rewards in marathons could be gratifying, but the effect
at a certain point goes haywire. "I get sick to my stomach.
Every time I hit about 25- or 30K I have to throw up. You can't
beat the elites when you're doubled over by the side of the
road. What should I do? Any ideas?"
Osprey has a lot of practical wisdom for all his youth. "Take
a pain reliever an hour or so before the race. I've been doing
that for a while now."
Davida, aside from a go-for-the-jugular competitiveness,
has nothing going for her if not ideas. But before she makes
adjustments to Morris's preparations she has to find out
some background. "Are you carbo-loading?"
Morris looks sheepish. "It's a psychological thing. If I don't
get something down ahead of time, I feel like I'm going to
die on the course. I eat breakfast on race day, even if I have
to get up way early."
Davida says, "It won't help anyway. The body can't
metabolize food that fast. You've got to figure out when to
carbo-load. It might be the evening before a race. It might be
even earlier in the day. Your body's rhythms should set the
time."
"I know all that. It's a ritual, you know?"
"You're only fighting yourself. Your animal side's in conflict
with your rational side. You crave food, then it ruins all you've
trained for by weighing down your system."
Osprey says, "Maybe he's just got a delicate stomach."
Morris says, "Actually I've been diagnosed with
irritable-bowel syndrome."
Osprey gives him a sidelong look of surprise and
sympathy. "Try the pain relievers."
Experimental medicine over years inventoried an
abundance of information and substances competitive
runners need to achieve fitness. Someone, somewhere, did
all the research into the settling effects of buffers in pain
relievers on digestive tracts; someone, somewhere, did all
the replication and verification of the research; someone,
somewhere mixed and packaged the results as pills.
Someone, somewhere, synthesized for popular
consumption all the scattered knowledge about the human
body's tendencies in metabolizing carbohydrates.
Osprey never tested aspirin against a placebo in a
double-blind experiment. Davida never drew blood samples
to check the effect of a high-carb diet on blood sugar. Morris
never analyzed a fecal sample to confirm his syndrome.
All three believe in found truths.
It's an enigma of modern civilization that millions of people
accept and apply knowledge garnered from a discipline,
science, the methodology of which they reject as cold,
soulless, godless. Dawkins, a biologist and fierce defender
of science, wrote in "A Devil's Chaplain" of the loyalty of
people to a list of cultural givens they ingest with their
upbringing: "Scientific truth is the only member of the list
which regularly persuades converts of its superiority."
Davida follows the truths of science if they lead to practices
that satisfy her goals. She's happy to pass them along as
advice to Morris on how to solve problems, as long as he
observes some decorum. "As long as he doesn't start
talking about bowel movements."
Getting Armstronger
Jackie Arbovoid entertains friends while munching a bagel
and sipping Gatorade after a race. Jackie might attract such
a circle after any running event anywhere in the state. She
has lots of friends.
She tells today's circle she'll move her 5K times into the
17s and her 10K times into the 36s by fall. "I increased my
baseline fitness at the Great Lakes Relay. That's why I did it.
Now it's just a matter of mixing speed work with endurance
runs."
Babs Uccello happens by as Jackie holds forth. A woman
of mature years and ample flesh, of jolly personality and
shrewd eye, Babs volunteers at races at the drop of a hat.
She gives Jackie a once-over look. "You're past college
age."
"Twenty-six."
"And your time today?"
"Eighteen forty-nine."
"And your best time?"
"Eighteen thirty-six."
"I don't think I'm going out on a limb if I say you've gotten
pretty close to the edge of your envelope."
"I should hope not."
"Have you heard about the physiology of Lance Armstrong?"
Jackie shakes her head as if wondering whether she's
admitting to ignorance of a subject she's supposed to know
... or wondering what the question's got to do with anything.
Babs says, "Armstrong was born to race bicycles over
mountains. His heart pumps almost double the volume of
blood per beat as the average person. His lungs convert
more oxygen. His blood has more red cells to carry it. His
muscles build up less lactic acid. Because of all that, he
recovers faster than his competitors. That's why he wins the
Tour de France every year."
"So?"
"It's genetics. Nobody can train for greater pumping volume
or for better chemistry. They can only train their hearts to
hold stress levels for longer periods of time, half an hour for
a 5K, three hours for a marathon. They can't train
themselves into Lance Armstrong."
Jackie says, "Well, thanks for nothing."
Babs walks away with a jolly laugh. Jackie mutters curses
and contradictions at her back until one of the circle tells her
the fat lady once sprinted her way to notoriety at an Olympic
trials.
Knowledge of blood circulation grew from roots in a
scientific breakthrough by William Harvey. The English court
physician in 1628 published "On the Movement of the Heart
and Blood in Animals." Like his contemporary, Galileo, who
upset the orthodoxy of divine motion in the heavens, Harvey
upset the medical orthodoxy of Galen, whose authority had
been sacrosanct for centuries.
Harvey did so with careful observations that proved the
heart pumped blood through a contained system of valves,
ventricles, arteries and veins.
Lactic acid became the suspect in muscle fatigue, the
cause of the wearying of athletes during exertion, with
publication of research by Archibald Vivian Hill in 1929. Hill's
work with frog muscles suggested function diminished with
accumulation of lactic acid and recovered with its removal by
nitrogen. But experiments since the 1960s cast doubt on the
findings, suggesting a beneficial influence on function by
lactic acid, part of a chemical complex that promotes
muscle contraction.
Beginning in 2001 potassium replaced lactic acid as a
favorite among supposed culprits in muscle fatigue.
Davida needs convincing. "Isn't it just like scientists to say
one thing for 70 years and then say the opposite? But then,
just to be safe, maybe I'll cut down on bananas."
Faster by Design
Mary Spotcheck has never worked out hard enough to
sweat in her life, let alone raced. Her look's office-chic rather
than exercise-sleek. But Mary brings her cheery glow to a
race here and there during the summer, backing her
daughter, Shy, who's keeping fit between racing seasons at
her university. Mary's met Saul Billiams a few times; he
belongs to Shy's set in terms of talent and dedication.
But Mary's never talked with Saul until an August morning at
a race by the big waters. She wonders why he's standing
around while Shy cruises through a 10K. "You, young man,
are no idler."
Saul says, "Did the 5K."
"And how did you do?"
"Went under 15 minutes. First time since I graduated."
"Are you through with college, then? My, how time flies. The
university must have had a hard time replacing you."
"Nah. There's plenty where I came from. I wasn't even the
fastest guy at my college from my own hometown."
Mary's impressed when he says the name of his native city.
"I remember somebody saying that some of the best track
programs in the country have a runner from your hometown.
Is it something in the water?"
"Nah. Selective breeding."
"I beg your pardon."
"Selective breeding. You know; like dogs, or cattle, or
sheep. You bring together people with traits you want to
pass on to children. I'm living proof."
"But that would mean your parents ..."
"Were part of an experiment? Actually they got recruited.
Actually they got ordered. Don't forget about the army base
in my hometown."
"Are you telling me your parents had no choice?"
"Dad would never have chased mom down. She was a
sprinter. He was a distance guy. That's why I can sprint for a
5K."
"Things like that do not really happen, young man."
"Not any more. Except at one or two universities. Probably
not at Shy's school."
Alfred Russel Wallace, while collecting specimens in the
Malay Archipelago in the first half of the 19th century, had
momentous insights into the origin of species. Even the
father of the Theory of Evolution, Charles Darwin, failed to
grasp the genius of Wallace's vision of the drift of inherited
characteristics.
David Quammen in "The Song of the Dodo" described how
even scientists ignored seminal 1855 and 1857 papers by
Wallace regarding speciation on Sarawak and the Aru
Islands. "This is typical of the way Wallace's work has been
overlooked, dismissed and forgotten. The Aru paper lies
interred, like a Gnostic gospel, in a cave of oblivion."
Gregor Mendel in 1856 in Brunn (now Brno), Moravia,
began hybrid research with peas. Andrea Barrett, in the
short story "The Behavior of the Hawkweeds," wrote, "...
Mendel performed hundreds of experiments on thousands
of plants, tracing the ways in which characteristics were
passed through generations." By 1865 he completed his
project.
"Mendel knew nothing of genes or chromosomes or DNA,"
Barrett wrote, "but he'd discovered the principles that made
the search for those things possible."
Unfortunately his reading of a paper on his findings fell on
deaf ears with fellow scientists. "Only in 1900 was his lost
paper rediscovered and his work appreciated by a new
generation of scientists."
Wallace and Mendel might have seconded each other,
strengthening their groundwork, but each toiled in ignorance
of the other's complementary breakthrough.
Over the course of a century and a half, as scientists got the
message and got on the case, an overwhelming body of
observation and experimentation proved the principles of
speciation and genetics pioneered by Wallace and Mendel.
But the public never got the message. A 2005 poll found 64
percent of Americans favored creationism and 22 percent
evolution. Few of the 64 percent, though, suffering an
inherited disease, would refuse a cure arising from the
human genome project, a descendant of Wallace and
Mendel through molecular biology.
Davida follows the profitable side of the
creationism-evolution divide. "I'm all for intelligent design.
It's intelligent to design a faster running body. Fit me with
the first one out of the vat."
Warp Speed
Sangfreud Sessob rubs elbows mostly with runners of his
own age and speed class. But by temperament, if no one in
his category is handy, Sangfreud rubs elbows with anyone
who comes within hailing distance. When on a spring
morning he finds himself in the pre-race company of Victor
Challenger, an elite middle-distance man from out of state,
he rubs elbows.
He tells Victor his plan for the event. "I'm still doing both the
5K and 10K. But it's going to be slow going. I had a little
quad strain this week and only did 63 miles."
Victor says, "You keep that close a distance log?"
"Right down to the tenth of a mile. Don't you?"
"Nope. Two years ago I started logging time along with
distance. Hours and minutes of cardiovascular exercise.
Then I saw it was a better way of fine-turning my training.
About a year ago I dropped the mileage part altogether."
"And you're getting better training?"
"Yup. Better results. A mile's just a mile. But an hour might
be so many minutes at a low heart rate, so many minutes at
a moderate heart rate, and so many minutes at an elevated
heart rate."
"You're telling me you log the difference?"
"Yup."
"I'll be a monkey's uncle. I got to try that."
Albert Einstein fused time and space into a single
gravitational package almost a century ago with the theories
of Relativity and Special Relativity. Within 10 years Werner
Heisenberg and other quantum mechanics jimmied
Einstein's elegant universe, introducing uncertainties he
never came to grips with, showing that the laws of a
gravitational macrocosm went kerflooey when applied to a
nuclear microcosm. To this day the relativists and the
quantum mechanics seek in vain for a single package of
laws to explain everthing from the vast to the minute.
String theorists insist they're on the brink of answering the
riddle with a concept of energy strings so tiny they elude
experimentation.
Conceptual differences among physicists couldn't prevent
the delivery of technologies to the general public that flowed
out of nuclear research. The common man and woman
might dismiss the competing theories as illogical, as
counterintuitive, but few if any ever disconnected from the
power grid because a portion of their electricity came from
esoteric knowledge of the invisible atom.
Davida has to stop and think about it all. "Einstein and
those quantum guys couldn't see eye to eye, but they got
together and made hydrogen bombs and nuclear power
plants. Sangfreud knows his mileage, but not if he knows
his time. Victor know his time as long as he wears a heart
monitor, but not if he knows his mileage. Is that what we're
saying? I'm confused."
Seeing the Light
String theory is the sexiest subject in the cosmos for writers
on popular science.
In an article for Smithsonian Magazine, "The Year of Albert
Einstein," author Richard Panek revealed how the iconic
scientist acted out the obsessions of today in advance.
Panek wrote, "... to the increasing exasperation of
colleagues, he spent the last three decades of his life trying
-- without success -- to find a grand unified theory that
would banish such uncertainty."
In his book, "The Theory of Everything," physicist Stephen
Hawking looked forward to the teaching in a simplified form
of a unified theory, once the breakthrough comes, to young
students. Hawking wrote, "We would then all be able to have
some understanding of the laws that govern the universe
and which are responsible for our existence."
Yet science writers to date have failed to grasp the source
of fascination in string theory. Not only could it wrap all the
cosmic forces into a neat gift, but because of its intuitive
nature, it could invite a melding of spiritualism, philosophy
and science.
Runners could find all the goods they desire in one
conceptual store.
In an article for the New York Times, "A New View of Our
Universe," science reporter Dennis Overbye edged toward a
grasp of the promise of a theory of everything. Overbye
wrote, "If the universe is big enough, ... everything that can
happen will happen, so that if we could look out far enough
we would eventually discover an exact replica of ourselves."
Yes.
That's the light in a running theory of everything.
Davida sees it. "Finally I come to know myself." MR